hey peggy, looks good. i love the shiverpool one, but i think the forest one is missing the mark in some places. i dont think it's a good piece to study, there's alot of weird decisions he made that are hard to follow. i think doing one with a color scheme that is easier to understand would be a better choice. i think u would probably learn more as well. keep up the work, paul lasaine is a great choice to study.
A great start here. Just kidding :PYour making delicious progress. The ice one is looking really good. I have some problems with the forest one though. The blue light looks awkward. I think its because the sky in the background is purple (would make sense if the bounce light was somewhat purple, too) it would also be cool if you work on your brush stroke economy and only use as many of them as you really need (the tree on the left looks a little messy) but anyway. i love it. give us more